Showing posts with label racism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label racism. Show all posts

Thursday, May 15, 2008

Arugula-Eater?

New York Times columnist Frank Rich humorously reported Senator Clinton’s characterization of Barack Obama as an “elite and condescending arugula eater.”

Relatively uneducated white voters in the lower economic classes do not see their values reflected in Obama. Somehow, they see themselves to a greater degree in Clinton. Why?

Senator Clinton is well-educated, and no voter paying attention to the primaries thinks otherwise. She is obviously not a member of the blue collar, working class. The policy differences between the two candidates is negligible. If gender were the issue, it would work against Clinton. So why is she a better mirror than Obama? Hmmm…

In West Virginia, 20 percent of respondents said that race was a factor in their decision and those voters, by overwhelming number, backed Mrs. Clinton.

“Downscale” white voters (as the pundits call those with little formal education and few financial assets) are afraid, or at least suspicious of Obama, because of what his color suggests about non-mainstream ethnic, religious, political and cultural values. His “funny” name reinforces the idea that he is “not one of us.” Some of these voters have said as much to pollsters.

Obama’s color is taken by these voters as a pointer to alien social and cultural values. The Reverend Wright episode reinforces that view for them. We can’t elect somebody we don’t even know! What if he sold the Louisiana Purchase back to France?

Consider also that 80% of black voters now support Obama. You might expect black voters to divide between the candidates much as white voters do. Even allowing that median incomes and educational levels may be lower for black voters, you would have a hard time explaining 80% favoritism on the basis of demographics.

It’s racism, just as it is for the downscale whites, but for black voters brown skin is a symbol for brotherhood and shared values. Both groups make the error of taking skin color as an index to who the person is. Blacks especially, should know better.

When downscale whites tell pollsters they are “uncomfortable” with Obama, they are expressing their true feelings based on their limited experience. I don’t think they are hate-mongers, just uninformed people with narrow life experience and limited conceptual skill. You wouldn’t blame an elephant for being an elephant and it’s hard to blame these people for their racism. (I know that sounds like I eat arugula).

Can Obama do anything to persuade these voters, who have so far preferred Clinton? I don’t think it is effective to dramatize the “plain folks” stereotype as Clinton so insincerely has. She probably believes that worked for her, but it is her white skin that worked.

The Bubba voter does not want to see Obama bowl again or watch him throw back a shot of Jim Beam. They might take notice if Obama revealed his values and the reasons for them. Voters want him to say, in plain terms, not vapid abstractions, what he really believes and why he believes it, about educational priorities, farm subsidies, military readiness, industry regulation, gun control, social security, taxation, carbon capture, the electricity infrastructure, government corruption by big money, oil dependency, the “war” on drugs, immigration, and so on. They do not want platitudes and policy statements, but the personal thought processes that brought the man to those beliefs. Actually, I would like that too.

Monday, April 21, 2008

Is Obama Like Me?

On Friday, major pundit and New York Times columnist David Brooks assessed the impact of Obama’s “bitterness” remark, on PBS’s The News Hour. Brooks said that the tin-eared remark was damaging because it made people step back from the candidate and wonder if he really is like the “plain folks” he is trying to appeal to in Pennsylvania, or if he is condescending to them. And, Brooks concludes, throwing in the Reverend Wright episode for good measure, when that assessment is made, the plain folks will conclude, “he is not like me.”

This is treacherous ground for Brooks, or any commentator to tread, for “not like me” is the heart of xenophobia, which is the core of racism. Racism today is no longer about hooded sheets and a noose. It is about the intellectual and emotional capacity, or lack of it, to get past one’s discomfort with the unfamiliar to understand that the other person is, in fact, “like me.”

People do differ in their socialization history and demographic status, and that does produce variations in point of view. I have no doubt that Obama is more educated, more self-aware, and more articulate than most of the Pennsylvania voters he courts. He is indeed, “different” from them in those ways and that makes his campaign a tricky business.

Obama’s political mistake was in the word “cling,” which implies a desperate helplessness and lack of dignity. That implication is indeed demeaning (even if true) and he should have retracted it. Instead, he blindly spun his use of “bitterness,” which is defensible and even could be construed as a compassionate attribution. Nobody in his camp seems to have gotten the social phenomenology of his remark right.

But why should a minor discourse error be elevated to the existential question, “Is he like me?” What is the logic that gets you from “I am offended by your remark,” to “You are alien to all people like me”? It is the logic of class difference, xenophobia, and the logic of racism.

Hilary Clinton is not at all like me in social class, education or even gender. I do not want to have a beer with her. In fact I am offended by her shameless, inauthentic pandering. But I would still vote for her on the basis of her social values and perceived competence to govern. That’s all Obama asks for himself, but the racial issue lurks just beneath the surface ready to trip him up. A smart guy like Brooks should be more aware of that particular tiger pit.

We should generously assume Brooks was speaking for the Pennsylvania rural voter, not for himself, when he concludes that Obama is "not like me." And in that assessment, Brooks might be correct. But he did not qualify his comments carefully, so missed an opportunity to raise the quality of political discourse in this country. Pity that.

Thursday, March 20, 2008

Obama on Race

Illinois Senator and presidential candidate Barack Obama delivered a speech on race in America, on March 18, 2008, in Philadelphia. The speech has been analyzed extensively in the media. It is widely available online, but in case you can’t find it, I have saved a copy at the URL at the end of this article.

News commentators predictably, witlessly, and cynically ask their pundits, “Has he put this issue behind him now?” As if the most divisive social issue in our nation’s history could be “put behind” anyone who lives here. The writers of the U.S. constitution could not “put it behind them” and had to finesse the issue of slavery, granting the states twenty years to come up with a solution. They didn't and the civil war broke out. Slavery was finally outlawed but not racism, which continued. The civil rights act of 1964 outlawed overt manifestations of racism, but of course, not racist attitudes, which persist to this day.

The analysts and pundits are ostensibly talking about Obama’s minister, Jeremiah Wright, who has a history of making flamboyant remarks from the pulpit, critical of American government and American white society for (in his view) deliberately and systematically oppressing the black populace, historically and even now. Many of his assertions are plainly demagogic and deliberately hyperbolic, and some are just ignorant, such as his claim that AIDS is promulgated by the government to decimate the black population.

What are the implications?
• Are we supposed to think that Obama believes the government is deliberately spreading AIDS?
• Are we to understand that Obama believes all white people are racist?
• Are we to suppose that Obama believes the 9-11 attacks were self-inflicted?
• Does Obama’s membership in the church imply that he is a racist?
• Does Obama’s friendship with the reverend prove that Obama hates America?

These are ludicrous suggestions, so ludicrous that no one would dare speak them. Instead they remain unspoken innuendo. Ridiculous though they are, they persist for two reasons:

1. The news media are racist and love racism. They highlight it as luridly as possible whenever they can. Why? Because we live in a capitalist society. The job of the news media is primarily to sell advertising and only incidentally to be informative. Since separating people from their money is best done with emotion, not rationality, and since racism incites emotion, it follows as night follows day that the media prefer to display, not analyze racism.

2. Racism is endemic in the society. Not overt KKK terrorism, but the subtle fears and doubts we all have about anyone who is different. Alas, skin color is the scarlet letter of ethnicity. You see it coming and you react before you have a chance to discover the person. Not everyone has the mental skill to analyze that reaction, to break through the egocentric bubble that insulates us from anything that is not a mirror-image.

Obama, more than most people, certainly more than Hilary Clinton, has shown himself in public. He is giving us the opportunity to look behind the outer shell. But many people only see shells. So despite one of the most eloquent speeches ever given about race in America, many people still react only, or mainly, to skin color.

Will Obama’s speech change any minds about him? Not among those who lack the capacity for self-reflection. Racism (as with any form of xenophobia) is irrational, so by definition, no rational argument exists that can change it. But I personally have talked to two people who have changed their affiliation from Clinton to Obama because of that speech. Both individuals were impressed by its honesty and thoughtfulness. “Nobody could make that stuff up,” said one. “Even if you wanted to BS about race, you couldn’t think of those things to say.”

With this speech, Obama has revealed himself more than he ever has. I admire him for it. But to be honest myself, I wonder if it was politic. Up to now he had been pretending that he had no color and that we were color blind. Of course that couldn’t last. But he has such charm, intelligence, self-confidence, and oratorical gifts, I wonder if he couldn’t have bluffed his way past the color question. Because now that it has been articulated, we confront naked racism, not the malicious “I’m gonna git you” kind, but the instinctive fear of an image that takes a moment to recognize as oneself.

Obama's speech:
http://members.bainbridge.net/~bill.adams/Race%20in%20America.htm.

Tuesday, June 12, 2007

Immigration Reform: What’s the Objection?

I just spent (wasted) two valuable prime-time working hours searching the internet in an attempt to discover what the objections are to the senate proposal on immigration reform. I could not find any sensible arguments, so I still don’t know.

Senate bill S 1348 can be reviewed at http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/thomas.

The bill would allow illegal immigrants in the country before 2007 to receive renewable four-year visas after paying fees and fines, and eventually get on a path to citizenship.
(Sen. Sessions. Photo: Doug Mills, NY Times)

It would create a guest worker program that would give two-year visas to 400,000 workers a year, (amended to half that number, then further amended to expire after 5 years).

None of those programs would go into effect until additional border agents were hired and the construction of hundreds of miles of border fencing were completed.

Republicans especially are against this bill. Why? I struggled to find out.

Wages and Jobs?
North Dakota Democratic Sen. Dorgan says the guest worker program is part of a strategy to put downward pressure on American wages. Presumably, this “strategy” is pursued by business people, such as mega-farmers, hoteliers, and food processing firms. There might be some truth to that.

But what is the alternative? I just spent $150 in Seattle for one night in a clean but low-end hotel. I had a tiny room with a window overlooking a busy 6-lane highway. The room was colorfully illuminated all night by a giant, neon Pepsi sign across the street. That hotel probably pays $7.93 an hour, the minimum wage, to housekeeping and other staff. Some of the staff, perhaps most, may be legal citizens. It could just be coincidence that most of them speak only Spanish. To fill 100% of those jobs with legals, they probably would have to offer at least twice that, plus some kind of health plan. Since labor is the main cost, it is likely that the price of the room would at least double at the higher rate, probably more than double in order to fill all jobs with solid, low turnover, legal employees. A $250 room in a moderate hotel downtown would probably go for $500 to $800 a night.

Likewise, apples might cost $6 a pound instead of $2. Maybe more, because who would you get to do backbreaking orchard work in rural counties, even at $15? In general, we could probably look to a doubling or tripling of food prices, including fruits, vegetables, cereals and meat and fish.

Would consumers pay up? Maybe they would. Gas prices have tripled recently and nobody seemed to mind. Maybe it would be the same for food and hotels. It would be a heck of a shock to the economy in any case. It’s hard to imagine what it would do to the travel business and the food production and distribution industries. Certainly the people who worked in those industries would still not be able to afford their own product.

Personally, I would eschew hotels altogether at those prices, which would mean severely curtailing domestic travel. I would also alter my food-buying patterns to avoid supermarkets in favor of local growers. I would not even consider a restaurant. If most people did the same, it would radically change the U.S. economy.

If consumers pushed back against the higher prices, which seems likely, the affected industries would move out of the country, for food, or close up shop altogether, for most hotels. That would ripple into the entire travel industry, and much of the entertainment industry as well. In turn, that would drastically affect municipal tax systems in unpredictable ways. I haven’t even considered the effects on restaurants and other industries that are price-supported by illegal workers at low wages. But for sure, a vast number of businesses and jobs would be lost without that support.

But such economic and social upheaval is apparently a fair tradeoff for people like Senator Dorgan. I think it’s far too radical. Can this really be a serious objection to immigration?

Amnesty?
Republican senator Sessions of Alabama is among the conservatives resisting the proposed immigration bill. In the New York Times of June 7, he is quoted, “I just don’t think that all 12 million people, including single people who broke the border last December, need to be put on a guaranteed path to citizenship.”

Why don’t these people “need” a path to legitimacy? Because they are law-breakers, criminals. They sneaked into the country and that’s against the law; thus the term “illegal immigrants.” Conservatives, who call the senate bill an “amnesty,” complain that it would reward law-breakers.

Anyone who reads the bill certainly knows that it is not a simple forgive-and-forget amnesty. Assuming that conservatives like Mr. Sessions have read the bill, they must be deliberately misrepresenting it for some reason. The only possible reason would be to hide other motivations, whatever those might be.

But suppose we did construe the bill as a limited form of amnesty. After all, the illegals are here illegally, and even after paying retribution and meeting other conditions, including returning to their home country, the fact that they could eventually return and apply for legal status, could be construed, in a tortured roundabout way, as a kind of amnesty. Let’s just say it is, for sake of argument.

What would be wrong with that? Why is amnesty a bad thing? It has been successful in solving social problems in many countries, notably South Africa of late, but also in the U.S. after our own civil war. What is this knee-jerk reaction against “rewarding” a misdemeanor offense? Could the argument be that it would start us on a slippery slope of rewarding all crimes? That’s just insane.

The reaction against amnesty seems to amount to nothing more than petulant pride, as if the granters of such “rewards” would be somehow diminished by it. But it is not clear how they would be diminished. The objection on grounds of amnesty is an immature and irrational emotional reaction, not a reasonable objection.

Racism?
Is there a hidden racist agenda in objection to immigration reform? Are conservatives afraid of being overrun by hoards of brown people?

I think there is a lot of that sentiment, although it cannot be spoken in polite company. I gather that impression from remarks overheard in border states such as California and Arizona.

I also get this impression from my own experience driving north between San Diego and Los Angeles through the hills east of the coastal freeways, or coming north into Tucson from the border. There are numerous Border Patrol checkpoints, through which every vehicle must pass in single file. The uniformed, weapon-bearing, mirror-sunglassed officer looks through your windshield to see if the driver is brown or white, and being white, I get waved through on a rolling stop with a flick of the finger. No words are exchanged.

These checkpoints are humiliating to me as an American, and they don’t even inconvenience me. If the Border Patrol at least compared my ID to a database of bad guys, I would feel there something more at stake than pure racism.

According to Wikipedia, the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) is a non-partisan, non-profit educational organization that advocates reform of U.S. immigration policies to improve border security and stop illegal immigration, and to reduce even legal immigration into the United States to around 300,000 people a year. In 2005, an article in the liberal political magazine, The American Prospect, called FAIR "the anti-immigration movement’s most powerful institution".

Yet disturbingly, according to the article, FAIR has been criticized for accepting contributions from the Pioneer Fund, which was described by a Wall Street Journal editorial as a "white-supremacist outfit devoted to racial purity through eugenics.”

One must not accuse all objectors to immigration reform of being racists because of a few associations like the one mentioned above, but we can at least observe that racism is a documented component of some immigration reform sentiment.

Xenophobia?
Another objection to immigration reform is the hint of old-fashioned xenophobia, irrational fear of someone different. It’s just this side of racism, not yet as pernicious. I heard some Senator on television (didn’t get his name), whining that when he was on vacation in a small town in a border state he could not find a store where English was spoken. He was apparently horrified at the prospect of bilingualism or multilingualism in America. Why? Presumably because he doesn’t happen to speak any languages but English.

Bilingualism is already a fact of life in the Southwest. The population of Los Angeles is 53% Latino now. And anyway, what is wrong with bilingualism? It enriches the mind and the culture in general.

I think this objection boils down to an irrational fear reaction. I saw a telling comment on some news blog: “Send all the illegals back to fix their own countries and not ruin ours by trying to make us like them......I AM NOT SPANISH AND DON'T WANT them here!”

I can sympathize with the fear that ignorance breeds, but it surely cannot be taken as a rational reason to oppose immigration reform.

Populism?
I could find only one sensible reason for opposing immigration reform, but it is not one that any critic of the senate bill cites. That reason is that most Americans are against immigration of all kinds, legal or illegal, and have been for a long time, even though most Americans are descended from recent immigrants. It’s the “close the door behind me” (CDBM) syndrome. Every national poll on the topic since 1976 has shown that a majority of Americans desire to cut immigration.

A recent Roper poll found that 70 per cent of all Americans wanted immigration levels between zero and 300,000 people annually. America's long-term immigration tradition before Congress changed the law in 1965 was a little over 200,000 a year; it was 178,000 a year for the forty years before that.

The Roper survey also found that among affluent Americans, only 11 per cent favored immigration levels above 300,000, and among Americans who identify themselves as Republican, sentiment runs 20 to 1 against the current immigration level of about 600,000.

In a recent USA Today/Gallup poll, 30% of Americans oppose the senate bill and 11% favor it. (The rest don’t know enough to have an opinion). Among critics, 39% cite "amnesty" as a reason for their opposition.

The plain fact is that most Americans do not support any kind of immigration. Politicians, as elected officials of the people, according to one theory of government, have the duty to express the will of their electorate and therefore they should loudly and vociferously oppose any immigration reform that amounts to anything other than a policy of shut the doors and close the windows on America. That’s what the people want.

Yet according to a slightly more sophisticated theory of government, politicians are leaders. As leaders it is their duty to explain to their constituents that their own self-interests are not well-served by ignorance, fear and racism. Unfortunately, instead of leadership, we see only posturing and hear only euphemism.

If anti-immigration conservatives were honest, they would state that their objection to the senate bill is the “closed door” policy that their constituents want. No one could accuse them of dark and dishonest motives if they did that.